Jump to content
DavidL

Resolene/ Neatsfoot/ Leather Balm With Atom Wax All The Same?

Recommended Posts

This question is for leather finishing.

Which finish has-

best protection

less distortion/ no darkening of leather

Shine finish

matte finish

Distinct smell

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your answer is similar to "Which is the best football team?"

My answers would be Resolene and Pittsburgh Steelers, . . . but there are those who disagree.

The steelers will break your heart sometimes, . . . and Resolene will darken your project a tad, . . . but both are still great, . . . and Resolene offers protection against UV which is important to me.

May God bless,

Dwight

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Neatsfoot oil is a conditioner, not really a finish, and it will darken leather. Resolene is the choice of many here especially when weather resistance is a big factor. Leather balm will give you a glossy finish but I've got it on my checkbook that I made five or so years ago and it has held up well.

Bob

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Neatsfoot is a conditioner. Apply it after you carve/dye leather. Can be replaced with EVOO.

Resolene is an acryllic finish. Gives better weatherproofing but leaves a less natural looking finish. Can be replaced by leather sheen.

Atom wax, aussie, sno seal, beeswax/oil blend, carnauba, dri-boot are all wax-based finishes. They give a more natural feel & look but less splash protection and they have to be re-applied on a regular basis.

Acrylic finishes do not give an aged look like wax-based finishes.

Living in Scotland, I am pretty much forced to use resolene to protect leather from the rain. Also, I never use wax-based finishes on carved pieces.

Long way to find the best finish is to buy & try them all. Quick way is to learn how to use resolene =)

Gloss/matt look can be controlled by the top coat: carnauba or kiwi shoe polish will give you a wide range of matt to gloss depending on how well you buff them.

Edited by Chavez

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

so much info to take in . Seems like resolene is a popular finish, I'll will give it a shot. I have atom wax and the finish is shiny.

Neatsfoot is a conditioner. Apply it after you carve/dye leather. Can be replaced with EVOO.

Resolene is an acryllic finish. Gives better weatherproofing but leaves a less natural looking finish. Can be replaced by leather sheen.

Atom wax, aussie, sno seal, beeswax/oil blend, carnauba, dri-boot are all wax-based finishes. They give a more natural feel & look but less splash protection and they have to be re-applied on a regular basis.

Acrylic finishes do not give an aged look like wax-based finishes.

Living in Scotland, I am pretty much forced to use resolene to protect leather from the rain. Also, I never use wax-based finishes on carved pieces.

Long way to find the best finish is to buy & try them all. Quick way is to learn how to use resolene =)

Gloss/matt look can be controlled by the top coat: carnauba or kiwi shoe polish will give you a wide range of matt to gloss depending on how well you buff them.

So I can use saddle soap to clean the leather, apply my dye, add the resolene/atom wax, then the kiwi polish? or will the mixture of this cause a bad reaction? Its a lot of questions, but I'm about to make a purchase and would like to get the proper stuff.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I dye without cleaning anything first.

1) Dye (I cut fiebing's pro with isopropyl alcohol at least 50/50). Let dry for a day or two.

2) Oil. (Evoo in my case as there's always some in the kitchen). Leave for a couple days for the oil to absorb.

3) Finish.

Usually, a few coats of 50/50 mix of resolene & water.

If I want a natural finish, I'd use an extra coat of mink oil and then a heavy coat of carnauba/aussies.

4) Top coat. Carnauba creme for resolene.

Kiwi neutral shoe polish for "natural" finishes.

For a starter, I'd say use 50/50 mix of resolene applied by dampening a sponge and rubbing it in circular motion - do 3-4 coats.

If you overapply resolene you end up with a horrible plastic look & feel =(

PS On unfinished leather I found atom wax and carnauba often bring out a lot of dye particles to the top of the grain, leading to crazy crocking. Carnauba is fine when it goes on resolene though.

PPS If you ask 10 leatherworkers about their conditioning/finishing process, you'll get 12 different answers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

PPS If you ask 10 leatherworkers about their conditioning/finishing process, you'll get 12 different answers.

^^^ The most accurate statement regarding finishes and techniques I've ever read.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...