I wanted to say thanks to everyone for the advice. I ended up fixing the project and it turned out nice considering it was a mess earlier. I was kind of surprised to find that I didn't even have to use the black oil dye to fix it up. All I did was put 2 more coats of the same spirit die on it, added more in spots that wasn't soaking it as well, then buffed.
If I run into issues again, your suggestions will definitely help. Again, I appreciate it.
Adam