Stohlmann And 5" Head Knives

[alexitbe]

Mr stohlman said they were no good and that 4" is ideal. Is this still the general consensus of opinion or can I get a 5" knife and not worry too much?

I have found a 5" one for a very good price.

Thanks

Alex

[zuludog]

Well, I've never used a round/head knife, but I'd say follow your own judgement.

Mr Stohlman is obviously good at leathercraft, but if you think a 5" knife would suit you, then get it, and learn to use it.

If you put 'leatherwork round knife' into the search box of YouTube there are several videos of them in use, that might help you to decide if the 5" will be OK

Edited January 20, 2015 by zuludog

[alexitbe]

Maybe, I shoul mention that I am new to leatherwork and have infact not made anything yet. I have, however, made a load of stuff which will allow me to do some leather work.... Getting the knife is the last act and then I am ready.

I actually fear using the round knife or more accurately sharpening it without ruining it. I would prefer to get a simple English style skiving knife (Have seen a new Adams one at a very good price) and a stanley knife, but have read Stohlman's books an he says that head knives are the way to go. Since I know nothing personally I thought I would follow what he says. However, there is a huge difference in prce bewteen the cheapest 4" and cheapes 5", although both are British made.