Rocket Scientist

Maybe some of you can help me out. I have had a recent problem finishing pieces with Leather Balm with Atom Wax. In the past, I have used this as a finish on dark pieces and have had good results. However, I recently dyed some pieces with Feibings Pro Oil Dye (English Bridle) and when I used the Leather Balm it resulted in dark splotches all over the pieces. I am applying with a cloth and rubbing it into the leather. Should I try a different way of applying it? Thanks.