Folks, I warn you: Do NOT do it!!
Well, in late spring last year I was tempted.
I ride Quarter Horses Western Style since 1971. My late father was a founding member of the German Quarter Horse Association.
Beside good horses we always had good saddles. I still own two made by the late John "Jack" Carroll of McNeal AZ, made after the ideas of Ol' Ed Connell.
In 1996 we imported a new horse from Washington State that needed a new saddle cause he was fairly wider in the withers than our older horses.
I was short of money at that time and quite curious, therefore I built a saddle myself, bases on a cheap Ralide tree.
I was aware of the fact that this kind of tree does not offer too much bearing surface due to short bars. Therefore I made efforts to block and plugs the skirts very well.
About Eastern 1997 I first used that saddle. And did about 3.500 hours (or about 15.000 miles) of riding in rough country on it during 13 or so years. I checked its fit to the horse regularely but the horse never ever complained or showed any signs of incovenience in his back....
When that horse turned 18 last spring I said to myself "He still seems to be in his prime, he merits a real good one..." I admit that I always dreamed of one of these nice Wade saddles.
I contacted a German saddle maker named Detlef Wilhelm. He came out to our place and we discussed all aspects of the project and first of all - of course - the brand, dimensions, shape of the tree. Detlef proposed a Bowden-Ritter tree and had some specimen with him.
He got the order but I obligated him to view the 4 hours of saddle making film turned bey Peter Campbell with Ol' Dale Harwood.
A week later I gave hima call and told him "Don't order that Bowden tree, I want something else, I'll order the tree by myself".
I got in contact with Denise Nikkel - by phone and by email - and 6 weeks later I owned a Rod-Nikkel-Wade-Tree. Detlef the German saddle maker came to fetch the tree and to look after his fit on the horse. We both had to agree that we never ever saw ´such a well made and good fitting tree (It is an entire little story how I got the shape of a horse in Germany over to Alberta).
To make an already long story not too long..... Right after New Years Eve I got my new saddle based on that Rod-Nikkel-Tree....
Detlef Wilhem did a real nice job, the hard seat of the saddle is so well shaped that I feel comfortable with it even after 4-5 hours of rough rding..... BUT, the most important, my horse, my ol' pal of many many miles, feels a lot better with that saddle. For the first hours of riding i did not feel much difference but that was probably due to the fact that we had lots of snow and riding was a little limited. After some longer rides of several hours I can feel pretty much difference in the attitude of the horse to show even a nice head set with an arced back after a long days. And you might imagine that I know this horse to the bone (like he knows me...)
The only possible reason can be a better fit and a larger bearing surface of the new saddle which is of course due to the tree...
So folks, again, do NOT do it.... because every time I ride the new saddle I am getting angry on myself! Why? Well, because I did NOT buy a saddle or at least a tree like that 10 years or so EARLIER.....
To be serious: The Nikkel Tree has cost me about 500 Euro more than a Bowden. And he is worth every single cent of it!
This cannot be proved with an Excel Sheet! But if you know horses they will tell you, clear and loud, in their own lingo...
Best regards from the Old World!