http://www.preservat...sloansaddle.php
Sorry, I was refering to these products. Preservation Solutions. The link didn't show. Perhaps these products are best left to professionals?
I do not think this saddle could, or should be made to look look like new. I appreciate the patina.
It has decorative rawhide buckstitching around all the the skirts edges and fenders.
This is the only place it still shows. It does not seem to be cleaning up enough to be visible on the rest of the saddle. I have never had any success getting rawhide tack to lighten up again once stained, so I was wondering if once the saddle is as good of a condition as I am capable of getting it, if replacing the rawhide stitching would be a reasonable undertaking.
I have always had well maintained tack, have never had to go beyond routine cleaning and conditioning, and have never dealt with a saddle that is this far gone. I have saddle soaped it again, it still looks dirty, but soaping it doesn't seem to be having much effect. The grime is deep in the leather, it still has a black/grey look in places.
Thanks again for your advice, I appreciate it.