I used 8-9oz Herman Oak from Springfield. I thought it was a good deal for $35, leftover shoulder from making belts. http://springfieldleather.com/30422/Shoulder%2CSingle%2CH-O%2C8-9oz/
Thanks for the encouragement, I never figured the first one would be close to a keeper as I was kind of hurrying thru, and kind getting a feel for it but I may just give it a go.
One question for the vetrans out there. It still feels a little soft, how do you get a holster rigid? It's pretty firm but not like some of my purchased ones.
Thanks for the motivation!