critique my first knife sheath

[Mablung]

43 minutes ago, bandanaman said:

We'll see how it holds up this fall on our elk hunts. I offered a do over but  my buddy seems more than happy to field test and go from there for now. I don't know why it didn't occur to me run a stich line at the bottom of the loop ....it would have been out of sight except for the backside.....Guess that's why they call it a learning curve.....

On the whole, the thing ought to be solid, and it really looks good. There’s nothing objectively wrong with doing it the way you did. It’ll work just fine. Don’t sweat it and let your buddy tell you the good, the bad, and the ugly about it, then tinker with it later. 

[ThisIsMyFirstRodeo]

If you really want me to critique it, the tooling isn’t up my alley, though I’m usually on the wrong side of the tracks…

From a design/construction standpoint, it looks better than anything I’ve made myself thus far. And to be clear, I haven’t even attempted tooling. So keep it up! Show us more!

 

[bigbird48]

I think you did a great job,        I agree on the rivet tho

[hking19]

Okay that's pretty amazing. I love the detailed work you put into it!