This Stuff Is A Little Confusing...

[CriticalRA]

I just finished my second cigar case and now before I stitch, I want to finish it. With so many different ways I am kind of at a loss as to what to use and how to use it. There is no tooling, it's just 3-4 oz. veg tanned belly leather. I want the antique look, so I was thinking 2 coats of Neatsfoot oil, applying Dark Brown Eco-Flow Gell, wipe, apply again, wipe and buff with some wool. This is just plain leather and I am not sure my process will make it look good? What would y'all recommend for this type of project?