In another forum I posted a picture of a holster I made:
Among the "Nice job" and "good work" posts, therre was this one:
"Actually, that is one beautiful holster. Nice work. VERY nice, in fact.
For those of us who can follow directions, did you ever consider open-sourcing a design, and publishing it as a PDF? I, for one, would likely be able to make it...it's the design process where I would fall down. Devil's in the details, y'know.
A series of community designed holsters for our beloved CZ82 would likely be a welcome addition."
Something just irritated me about this one. Here was my reply:
"I dunno... my leatherwork is kind of a "fallback position" if I should ever lose my job. I'm not sure I want to give away a design that I might have to rely on to feed my kids and pay my bills.
I might think about selling a DIY kit, though... "
I thought about it a bit and then posted this next:
"I'd also be willing to answer any holster design questions anyone has, or give advice on making them. After all, people helped ME when I needed it."
Here was the reply I got:
"Well, I did say *a* design. A few donations like that from a few members (XXXXXXX, for example, has also made holsters) and we'd have a library of designs from which to choose. The library could be expanded to include holsters for common pistols like the 82/83, various 75, etc.
Bottom line...your design is nice. However, your leatherworking skills are magnificent...it looks, not just "homemade" servicable, but beautiful. Even giving away the design, it is unlikely to noticeably impact your potential sales, because of your skill and the obvious quality of your product.
Anyway, the open source thing was just an idea. And, judging from the almost immediate response, it seems to be something that would be welcomed by the community. Heck, if I knew how to design a holster I'd start the ball rolling, myself."
I then said:
"I'd happily do a tutorial on holster making and design, if that would help."
Am I wrong here? I get where he's coming from- that forum is about a certain pistol, and there aren't a lot of folks making a holster for it. Having an open source design WOULD benefit them. On the other hand, how can you expect someone to just give away a design they developed? I get his point about skill, but it still doesn't sit right somehow...