Thanks chiefjason,
It was dyed. Funny thing about water based dye. If you dye it before you wet mold the holster, the dye likes to leave the leather when you put it into water. Lesson learned on that one. I was using ecoflo. I thought that the pieces were dry but I think I am going to try the Fiebings oil based offerings next time. The edges around the loops look like crap because I waited to cut them until the very end. Big OOPS. I also plan on getting a punch, at least for the ends of the holes cause my knife skills were not up to cutting those out. In the end its gonna stay looking like this but I'm already looking forward to making another one this weekend. Thanks for the tip on the burnishing. I definitely feel like this is one area that I'm going to have to work hard on until I get a good system down. Thanks for the tip about the saddle soap. I'll be sure and pick some up.