I'm collecting information on current judging/critiquing systems for evaluating leather projects. My intent is to create a report of "What's Done", followed by discussions/proposals for ideas on how to efficiently provide quality feedback to the craftsman. For example, different systems exist for the Federation, 4H, and the Boy Scouts. And, some Guilds have their own systems (I'm really interested in learning more about those.)
Of course, you can't standardize everything (and I wouldn't even want to try), but some people (like me) clearly need more guidance on seeking, receiving, and authoring critiques of our projects.
Please post links here, email addy removed for spam prevention by Johanna to any resources of which you're aware on score sheets, aspects, topics, categories, etc. For example, the Federation has categories of projects and some level of guidance on how to judge projects ... where's the most up-to-date version of that stuff?
Also, if you have thoughts, ideas, or suggestions on this topic -- I'M ALL EARS. (This topic is an interest of mine, and I'd really like to get my brain around it.)
I'm tempted to post this request on some leatherwork-specific email lists on the internet, but I'm not sure if that's a good idea (previous times when I've brought it up, I've gotten minimal response). Currently, I'm only talking about this topic here. Let me know what you think about that too.
Did I pick the right section in the Leatherworker.net forums? (Please correct me if there's a better section in this forum).
Thanks!
--charley