The Tandy guy steered me in the direction of using Fiebings Leather Balm with Atom Wax as a top coat and sealer. It buffs out to a nice shine, but not high gloss, and really helps the leather stay feeling good. I love the way it looks and feels. Here's my question: the black Eco Flow dye is bleeding through the balm, and when I take a slightly damp paper towel and rub it, I get the dye on it (I'm not rubbing vigorously or hard). So, did I not buff enough of the pigment off of the holster before applying this leather balm? Is leather balm not a suitably waterproofer/sealant?
Second finish - I picked up a bottle of Super Sheen. I was going for the high gloss finsih this time, and to my surprise, it made the leather feel more like plastic after I was done. I worked the holster in my hands for a bit, and didn't see any cracking in the finish, but it definitely made it harder. Is there anything that would help keep it slightly softer? The dye also bled through this stuff afterwards, although not as bad as the leather balm. Am I not buffing enough of the pigment off the holster before I apply the topcoat? Am I suppossed to buff like hell?
Any finishing tips using these two products would be great. Thanks!