JAM Report post Posted October 19, 2010 Hi, all, Here's my 4th saddle - it's a vaquero/buckaroo style Wade on a tree from Rod & Denise Nikkel: Wade fork Wade bars, 93 degrees 16" seat (rides like a 15-1/2" seat) all-leather ground seat all hand-stitching 5" Taylor cantle 4" horn cap 3/4 single ring rig (4" bronze rings from Bork) 4" treads in roper-style stirrups full stirrup leathers Hermann Oak leather Being just my 4th saddle, there is still much to learn - so I welcome any and all critiques. Thanks, Julia Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
alb Report post Posted October 19, 2010 Fantastic!!! I'd love to see the top of the horn and a close up pic of the carving on the fender if you happen to have additional pics. Nice job on the hidden stitch on the cantle binding. Ann Hi, all, Here's my 4th saddle - it's a vaquero/buckaroo style Wade on a tree from Rod & Denise Nikkel: Wade fork Wade bars, 93 degrees 16" seat (rides like a 15-1/2" seat) all-leather ground seat all hand-stitching 5" Taylor cantle 4" horn cap 3/4 single ring rig (4" bronze rings from Bork) 4" treads in roper-style stirrups full stirrup leathers Hermann Oak leather Being just my 4th saddle, there is still much to learn - so I welcome any and all critiques. Thanks, Julia Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Steve Brewer Report post Posted October 20, 2010 Jam,Looks nice and clean to me.I would turn my cantle a little bit more to keep your binding from rubbing on me.Over all nice job Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Tosch Report post Posted October 20, 2010 Hi Julia, we have'nt been in touch for quite a while. I was wondering what you were up to. Now I know.. great saddle! Thomas Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
jwwright Report post Posted October 20, 2010 Very nice Julia, good job. A couple things I would suggest.....................the cantle binding as Steve suggested, and I think I see a few "flat" or "straight" places on your skirt & rear jockey lines, maybe. Could be the camera angles. Also, as a matter of personal preference, I like to see a bit more length to the rear jocks for balance. Congrats, and nice job. JW Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JAM Report post Posted October 20, 2010 Fantastic!!! I'd love to see the top of the horn and a close up pic of the carving on the fender if you happen to have additional pics. Nice job on the hidden stitch on the cantle binding. Ann Thanks, Ann! Here are pics. The hidden stitch is not as perfect as I would like, but it's better than it used to be The cuts are freehand - I use dividers to mark spacing for the "pollywog" heads, then cut the pollywogs, then cut all the curves (first all the curves that go away-and-to-the-right, then all the curves that pull toward-me-and-to-the-right). It's a crutch to do them that way, I know, but it's how my fingers work best. I am not nearly as good as I hope to be one day - my heroes and inspiration are Claire Kehrburg and Rick Bean - and of course all my practice pieces are SO much better than the real pieces Julia Jam,Looks nice and clean to me.I would turn my cantle a little bit more to keep your binding from rubbing on me.Over all nice job Thanks, Steve - good call. I hadn't even thought of that, but now that you point it out, you are absolutely right. Hi Julia, we have'nt been in touch for quite a while. I was wondering what you were up to. Now I know.. great saddle! Thomas Thanks, Thomas! Yes, it's been a long time! And it's taken me a year and a half to finally finish this saddle (that's what comes from dithering as you go instead of having an overall plan before you begin). Julia Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
JAM Report post Posted October 20, 2010 Very nice Julia, good job. A couple things I would suggest.....................the cantle binding as Steve suggested, and I think I see a few "flat" or "straight" places on your skirt & rear jockey lines, maybe. Could be the camera angles. Also, as a matter of personal preference, I like to see a bit more length to the rear jocks for balance. Congrats, and nice job. JW Thanks, JW - these are good calls. The curves need work - it's not the camera angles <ggg> (I need to learn to use a french curve, I think). As for the jockeys - the skirts are an inch too long in front and in back (I think) and I knew that but didn't realize it until after the tooling, and at that point I didn't want to cut new skirts (I didn't have the leather). You are right, I should have lengthened the jockeys to balance the extra skirt length (and to give the bars a little more coverage). I'm having trouble drawing patterns for the full curve skirts I really want - the ones I see in pictures of other saddles. All these points will definitely go into the next saddle. It is so worthwhile to post pictures here and get input from all of you! Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites