I tried Roon for the first time on some 8 oz. and got a gray/dry looking finish that I haven't been able to get rid of yet. I did a 10 second in, 10 out, in, out, in, out. Let sit for 10 mins,then did about a 10 second bs wash, then rinse in tap water. 5 mins later oiled with pure neatsfoot oil - it was beautiful. Fast forward 18 hours, it now looks grayish-dry looking. I re-oiled it and returns the deep black finish but lasts until the oil soaks in. I've put 5 coats of the oil and let some sit without wiping off. It's a little better but won't stay deep black. Did I do something else wrong?