Resurrecting an old post, it appears. I am relatively new to leatherworking. I got some leather from the local craft store (ReaLeather), a pair of shoulders from Tandy, and some various bits n pieces - belt blanks, etc, from European Leather Works on Amazon. Nothing high end, but, I have churned out a purse for my wife, recovered a footstool, and made a checkbook cover for myself, a few belts, and have started churning out some cast iron pot holders.
I have been relatively satisfied by the leather I have gotten from Tandy, as being far superior to the ReaLeather and ELW stuff, from a tooling perspective. It has taken impressions well, stamped well, and, when I have kept my tools sharp, carved relatively easily - occasionally a little "draggy," but not anything I have been unable to control. I have never tried Hermann Oak. That's next on the list, and I am looking forward to it!
With all that said, I stopped by the Tandy store, this week, and picked up a small piece of the 5-6 oz Oak Leaf, to make the checkbook cover. Maybe because it was already stained, I found it pretty miserable to work with. When I sprayed it, to case and start tooling, the water just beaded up, so, I assume it had been "finished" in the store. I ended up spraying the back side to get it dampened. Once I had, it took impressions reasonably well (when hit with a heavy mallet), but did not carve nicely at all. Once I was done tooling it, I had a checkbook cover I was not too dismayed by. I used my airbrush to fade to black on the edges, and sealed the edges with Fiebings black Edge Kote, and it looks pretty decent. That said, I would not offer it up for sale. I don't intend to buy more; the plain shoulders I bought tooled much nicer.
The way I see things at this point, I can use the remainder of the shoulders I bought from Tandy to make some things for around the house, and make tap offs. I will look forward to seeing how those transfer to a premium leather, and am eager to try making some pieces to sell in the near future...