Thank you so much guys! I'm at work right now so I can't do much experimenting but will definitely get working when I get home.
The only reason we did our finishes on our final products was because we THOUGHT we had found the answer. *deep breath* With a much clearer, and drier head - lol, we're gonna take a step back and try all of the suggestions, baring that we can find the products, before we get going at it again.
Being that we're in Canada, there isn't a whole lot of leather shops or suppliers up here (well at least not in our area) but I did think about calling some of the Tandy managers in the States, so it's funny that you suggested it whinewine; I'll give them a call if I'm still running into problems.
I do think our main problem is the hi-lite. From the sounds of it, the Eco-Flo is crap so I think it's time to move on to bigger and better products.
Seriously, thank you for all the input, it has restored my faith that we will find what works for us.