did I buy fake neatsfoot oil?

[SUP]

"As has been said"... One way of putting it, I guess.😄

Different suppliers using different sources of varying qualities.

The oil thickening and turning liquid again I can understand. But if the oil has a rancid smell, I wonder whether it will not transfer to the leather and linger. 

[el_pipou]

Thanks to you all for your anwsers!

I bought some other cans from another brand and im back genuine neatsfoot oil.

I think the p.paulin maker puts lots of inferior products like lard and such wich go rancid and make for a product that isnt neatsfoot oil at all anymore. while it does nourish leather very very well it is barely liquid at room temperature, cloudy, and the smell does stay onto any piece of leather you put it on. it can only be found in france though so you wont have to worry about it

 

[kgg]

1 hour ago, el_pipou said:

I think the p.paulin maker puts lots of inferior products like lard and such wich go rancid and make for a product that isnt neatsfoot oil at all anymore.

Have you complained to the seller / vendor as they may not be aware of the rancid problem???

kgg