I agree on the poor tools, but disagree on the leather.
You see, there aren't 500 suppliers of leather in the US. There are only a few that control a large part of the market with regard to wholesaling it to retailers. And as you can imagine, the larger buyers get the better prices on much of the quality hides (post process). So unless you are telling me you're getting leather from Spain or Italy through an interemediary, the quality that you are referring is a mystery to me.
Retailers "go to market" once or twice a year to buy product, including leather. These Market Centers are located in major cities in the US and carry a variety of hides from suppliers. These suppliers push their product to every Market Center in the US they can to reduce the cost of shipping and containering and increase margin. So the product is pretty much the same everywhere you go in the US (Market Centers). This is where retailers buy their leather to sell you.
The less you buy, the more it cost. So it is logical to assume the larger buyers will get a better deal and be able to sell it pretty competitively, relatively speaking of course. And if you're buying a large order, you're not going to want to junk.
That said, if a retailer can establish a connection in South America, Spain or Italy and cut out the intermediary, they can pass along a unique and generally high quality product to the consumer. But this is rare as it requires the retailer to travel to a foreign country and source the hides themselves (and get them containerized to get home $$). And this can be done with the help of an envoy which are generally supplied by the US Embassy or country of origin's embassy for free. But then you end up driving around touring facilities all over the worst places on the planet.
So not to burst anyone's bubble, but the market in general has become globalized in the trade of hides and just about every other consumer product to reduce cost, increase distribution and maintain margin.
I'll provide some nice pics for you in the coming weeks as I go to market.