Would any of these sets be good?

[MasonLikesLeather]

I'm completely new.
1. Amazon.com: PLANTIONAL Leather Working Tools for Beginners: Professional Leather Craft Kit with Waxed Thread Groover Awl Stitching Punch for Leathercraft Adults Gifts 02
2. Amazon.com: TLKKUE Leather Tooling Kit Leather Craft Tools Leather Working Kit with Custom Handbag Cutting Mats Engraving Punching Sewing Stamping Sanding Tools Leather Tools for Leather Working Professional
3. Amazon.com: Leather Craft Tools, 60 Pieces Leather Working Tools and Supplies with Storage Bag Cutting Mat Prong Punch Groover Edge Creaser Stamping Carving Knife Awl Hammer for Leather Craft Making DIY Sewing
If none of these are good, do you guys have any recommendations?
Thanks!
-Mason

[elnedro]

@MasonLikesLeather Kinda depends on what projects you are looking to do.  

When I got started I just went to hobby lobby and got a basic set (had stamps and a swivel knife), a hammer and some leather rounds.  Probably spent $30 in all.  

Within a week I had basically replaced all of these with stuff from Tandy leather.  The cheaper stamps bend pretty easily.  

 

What I basically started with was a swivel knife, a hammer and the following stamps:

pear shader: https://tandyleather.com/products/craftool-smooth-pear-shader-stamp?_pos=1&_sid=a8c32ab79&_ss=r

beveler: https://tandyleather.com/collections/beveler-stamps/products/craftool-smooth-beveler-stamp

camouflage: https://tandyleather.com/collections/border-stamps/products/craftool-crescent-camoflage-stamp

veiner: https://tandyleather.com/collections/beveler-stamps/products/craftool-smooth-beveler-stamp

seeder: https://tandyleather.com/collections/seeder-stamps/products/craftool-seeder-stamp

 

I've gotten a lot more since, but those let me do the basics.

 

I'm not sure where you are located, so I don't know if a Tandy is inconvenient.  
 

I also had a number of books that I used for ideas in the beginning.  DM me and I can send you a couple of PDFs

[elnedro]

@MasonLikesLeather Oh, and I used belly leather to start out with. I don't really ever use it on leather projects, but its cheap enough to where I feel fine just used it to practice cuts and stamps.

 

[Mablung]

Depends on how much you want to get into floral tooling. Most of those stamp kits have large stamps that make it difficult to do anything precise. I’d follow elnedro’s advice and start out with some basic tools from Tandy. They’re better than kits you’ll get at other big box hobby stores but are not too expensive, either.

If you’re looking for basic floral carving tools, elnedro covered that. As far as tools for construction, I’d start with a 5mm six-prong and two-prong set of stitching chisels, a good mallet, and a groover or creaser from Tandy. That stuff will last you a long time and is decently made. I think I mentioned on another thread that something to mark hole locations and an awl work well, which is true. I do some of my stitching that way. I then thought about the fact that a good set of chisels is easier to use when starting out, IMO. The awl and over stitch wheel or pricking irons are definitely useful, but chisels are easier to start with. I’ll post some links when I have a chance. 

[bruce johnson]

Here is what I can recommend - https://twentythreeplus.com/collections/tools/products/beginner-tooling-kit

Joe is a good guy and sharpens the blade so you know how they should be instead of guessing with a dull blade. 

[DJole]

Check out these beginner-oriented videos from  Leodis Leather. He discusses what tools you might already have, what leather to use, and so on. 
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvoKYeh7ahyGB-numgnO3WxOVi3Sgkyzg

[zuludog]

Firstly, Welcome to the fun!

Secondly, I don't do carving/tooling/stamping

Generally speaking, the leather craft kits from Amazon aren't very good, and generally again, you'd be better off putting your money towards something better ----- on the other hand, if the price is very low you'll get a good selection for little money, so it might be worth a go just to try it and get started. And from the look of those kits some of the tools are reasonable enough, so even if you keep some and dump others the overall cost would still be reasonable.

However, paradoxically, if that's the right word, you need some experience to decide ..... like I said, welcome to the fun

I suggest you Search YouTube for 'beginners leather tools' and similar categories, there are several videos. Each one is similar but slightly different, reflecting the preference of the individual leather worker but watch a few and you'll get the general idea.

Also watch YT videos on making the items you fancy, such as wallets, belts, knife sheaths, pouches, and you'll see what other people use and how they do things There are also videos on techniques such as saddle stitch, edge finishing, sharpening edge bevellers, and so on 

Get a shopping list together and build up your tool kit as you need it

I only know a few suppliers in the USA - Weaver, Tandy, and Rocky Mountain Leather Supply, but I'm sure other people will add their suggestions. 

Edited July 4, 2024 by zuludog

[SUP]

@MasonLikesLeather, I started leatherwork as a hobby, last year in January. This is the kit I bought from Amazon. It is probably similar to ones you have listed. They all have more or less of the same items.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07QY7CP72/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&th=1

I bought the kit because I did not have a clue what I wanted to do; just that I loved leather and wanted to work with it! 

I am happy with that purchase. It gave me a chance to determine what I would actually like to do before I bought more expensive tools.  This set provided several items I have not needed to replace like the mat, the awl, the needles, scissors, snaps etc.  The quality is fine for a newbie to get an idea of the craft. I did need to buy stitching chisels but those too I got from Amazon and they work fine. The very expensive ones are probably wonderful,  but for me, as a hobbyist, the Aiskaer or Wuta or Owden (to which I am partial) work well enough that I have not needed to buy the more expensive ones.  I do have new stamps but those are things you can buy if you decide to go down that route. Leatherwork, especially in the beginning, is a journey of discovery. Take your time and enjoy it. 

Also, the French style chisels give beautiful stitches, but to learn, the  Japanese style ones are better. Saddle stitching takes a bit of practice to get beautiful stitches. Once you can get the angles with round or diamond shaped holes, you can get good stitches anywhere. No matter what you decide you want to make, saddle stitching is a basic leatherworking skill, needed everywhere. There are excellent videos teaching saddle stitching online and information about those videos on this forum.

 

Edited July 4, 2024 by SUP

[MasonLikesLeather]

2 hours ago, SUP said:

@MasonLikesLeather, I started leatherwork as a hobby, last year in January. This is the kit I bought from Amazon. It is probably similar to ones you have listed. They all have more or less of the same items.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07QY7CP72/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&th=1

I bought the kit because I did not have a clue what I wanted to do; just that I loved leather and wanted to work with it! 

I am happy with that purchase. It gave me a chance to determine what I would actually like to do before I bought more expensive tools.  This set provided several items I have not needed to replace like the mat, the awl, the needles, scissors, snaps etc.  The quality is fine for a newbie to get an idea of the craft. I did need to buy stitching chisels but those too I got from Amazon and they work fine. The very expensive ones are probably wonderful,  but for me, as a hobbyist, the Aiskaer or Wuta or Owden (to which I am partial) work well enough that I have not needed to buy the more expensive ones.  I do have new stamps but those are things you can buy if you decide to go down that route. Leatherwork, especially in the beginning, is a journey of discovery. Take your time and enjoy it. 

Also, the French style chisels give beautiful stitches, but to learn, the  Japanese style ones are better. Saddle stitching takes a bit of practice to get beautiful stitches. Once you can get the angles with round or diamond shaped holes, you can get good stitches anywhere. No matter what you decide you want to make, saddle stitching is a basic leatherworking skill, needed everywhere. There are excellent videos teaching saddle stitching online and information about those videos on this forum.

 

Thanks! This set will really help me out! I am planning on purchasing it soon. It seems to be at a good price, with good reviews. It also seems to have a good amount of items. Thanks for the tips!

2 hours ago, zuludog said:

Firstly, Welcome to the fun!

Secondly, I don't do carving/tooling/stamping

Generally speaking, the leather craft kits from Amazon aren't very good, and generally again, you'd be better off putting your money towards something better ----- on the other hand, if the price is very low you'll get a good selection for little money, so it might be worth a go just to try it and get started. And from the look of those kits some of the tools are reasonable enough, so even if you keep some and dump others the overall cost would still be reasonable.

However, paradoxically, if that's the right word, you need some experience to decide ..... like I said, welcome to the fun

I suggest you Search YouTube for 'beginners leather tools' and similar categories, there are several videos. Each one is similar but slightly different, reflecting the preference of the individual leather worker but watch a few and you'll get the general idea.

Also watch YT videos on making the items you fancy, such as wallets, belts, knife sheaths, pouches, and you'll see what other people use and how they do things There are also videos on techniques such as saddle stitch, edge finishing, sharpening edge bevellers, and so on 

Get a shopping list together and build up your tool kit as you need it

I only know a few suppliers in the USA - Weaver, Tandy, and Rocky Mountain Leather Supply, but I'm sure other people will add their suggestions. 

Thanks! I will definitely try to stop by some of those suppliers!

5 hours ago, DJole said:

Check out these beginner-oriented videos from  Leodis Leather. He discusses what tools you might already have, what leather to use, and so on. 
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvoKYeh7ahyGB-numgnO3WxOVi3Sgkyzg

Okay!

9 hours ago, bruce johnson said:

Here is what I can recommend - https://twentythreeplus.com/collections/tools/products/beginner-tooling-kit

Joe is a good guy and sharpens the blade so you know how they should be instead of guessing with a dull blade. 

Thanks!

[chuck123wapati]

19 minutes ago, MasonLikesLeather said:

Thanks! This set will really help me out! I am planning on purchasing it soon. It seems to be at a good price, with good reviews. It also seems to have a good amount of items. Thanks for the tips!

Thanks! I will definitely try to stop by some of those suppliers!

Okay!

Thanks!

There's about five things in that amazon set you will use for any length of time, most of it is pretty low rate tools, we used to call that stuff junk. If you have the money buy the kit Bruce Johnson linked at least you can sell it if you don't like leather work.