Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Members
Posted

Oh, this is exactly my kind of question!
Certified business consultant here 😉

A/B testing is your best friend — whether online or at fairs.

How it works

Create a small batch of Product A (e.g., watch straps) and Product B (e.g., journal covers). Photograph both well.

On social media

If you use Meta Business Suite, you can even target different groups.
Show Product A to Group A, Product B to Group B.
Let the test run for a few days up to a month, then compare:

  • likes

  • comments

  • link clicks

  • profile visits

Whichever product generates stronger engagement is the better performer.
This method is often more reliable than fairs because the data is cleaner.

At fairs

Best if both fairs are in the same region.
Bring slightly different assortments each time — more of Product A at one fair, more of Product B at the next.
Compare:

  • actual sales

  • total revenue

  • which product attracts more conversation or attention

You can A/B test pricing too

Announce Product A at Price X (production cost + 40% raw profit) to Group A, and Product A at Price Y (production cost + 56% raw profit) to Group B.
Check the same statistics as above plus any DMs or inquiries.
It’s an easy way to find your optimal price point.

Don’t forget the math

When you evaluate a product line, include:

  • production time (based on average hourly wage in your area)

  • material costs

  • packaging

  • share of workshop rent

  • tool depreciation (please don't forget that! Most hobbiest do and it's simply undermining the value) 

  • insurance

  • booth fees (for fairs) + costs to get to fair (fuel etc.) 

  • percentage of profit

  • cost of storage 

Calculate how many units you must sell just to break even.
Then look at how realistic that number is within your usual sales cycle.
That alone often reveals whether a product line is worth pursuing. Despite that also consider if things can be bundled or cross sold,  e.g If a person buys a watch strap, do they buy a matching belt? If so - make a bundle (a watchstrap and a matching belt together for production cost plus 45% profit so slightly cheaper together in a bundle, than as two seperatly chosen products, also advertise it as a great deal (even if it's not)) or at least a cross sale offer (the belt is suggested when someone looks at watchstaps or simply place the somewhat matching belts close by at your booth, that they are in eyeside together). Selling is simple psychology and not magic or high profile science you need countless degrees for, make use of it! 

Hope I was of help,
Best
Tove 

Posted
3 hours ago, Tove09Tilda said:

 

Oh, this is exactly my kind of question!
Certified business consultant here 😉

A/B testing is your best friend — whether online or at fairs.

How it works

Create a small batch of Product A (e.g., watch straps) and Product B (e.g., journal covers). Photograph both well.

On social media

If you use Meta Business Suite, you can even target different groups.
Show Product A to Group A, Product B to Group B.
Let the test run for a few days up to a month, then compare:

  • likes

  • comments

  • link clicks

  • profile visits

Whichever product generates stronger engagement is the better performer.
This method is often more reliable than fairs because the data is cleaner.

At fairs

Best if both fairs are in the same region.
Bring slightly different assortments each time — more of Product A at one fair, more of Product B at the next.
Compare:

  • actual sales

  • total revenue

  • which product attracts more conversation or attention

You can A/B test pricing too

Announce Product A at Price X (production cost + 40% raw profit) to Group A, and Product A at Price Y (production cost + 56% raw profit) to Group B.
Check the same statistics as above plus any DMs or inquiries.
It’s an easy way to find your optimal price point.

Don’t forget the math

When you evaluate a product line, include:

  • production time (based on average hourly wage in your area)

  • material costs

  • packaging

  • share of workshop rent

  • tool depreciation (please don't forget that! Most hobbiest do and it's simply undermining the value) 

  • insurance

  • booth fees (for fairs) + costs to get to fair (fuel etc.) 

  • percentage of profit

  • cost of storage 

Calculate how many units you must sell just to break even.
Then look at how realistic that number is within your usual sales cycle.
That alone often reveals whether a product line is worth pursuing. Despite that also consider if things can be bundled or cross sold,  e.g If a person buys a watch strap, do they buy a matching belt? If so - make a bundle (a watchstrap and a matching belt together for production cost plus 45% profit so slightly cheaper together in a bundle, than as two seperatly chosen products, also advertise it as a great deal (even if it's not)) or at least a cross sale offer (the belt is suggested when someone looks at watchstaps or simply place the somewhat matching belts close by at your booth, that they are in eyeside together). Selling is simple psychology and not magic or high profile science you need countless degrees for, make use of it! 

Hope I was of help,
Best
Tove 

Everything you've said above is ok except for handmaking the product. Buying product from China (say) would work because you can buy to test and if it doesn't work you can junk it and choose something else until you light on the items that sell. Making something by hand that might take an hour or three or four or a day is a different thing altogether. To make enough product to go through what you're advocating would take some time and at the end of the process it could come to nothing and you've wasted a lot of time. I have a very logical mind and so wish it was as easy as you say but the variables when handmaking are different. When you have supermarkets and online stores sell substandard stuff it's hard. As I've said before many of the public don't know or care where it comes from or what it's made of and some of those that do simply can't afford hand made stuff. This why I've said that where you market your product is really important. Of course, a couple of years down the line, if you're doing a good job you might start getting commissions and even small contracts but until then it can be hard to even get back what you've put in.

  • Members
Posted

@Dwight that's  exactly what I do, I wear my wares. I have 3 belts with different  designs  that I wear regularly. My flip phone case is quite a fancy hand laced and hand stitched one with a fancy concho , and yes , I keep some business cards in my wallet. 

At the markets I have a few folders with heaps of pics of what  I have made, and custom work I have done and place them on my table for people to browse  through.

Word of mouth has worked better than paid advertising  , as for face book etc. , my customers  do that for me 

Great minds think alike  :specool:

HS

' I have a very gweat friend in Wome called Biggus Dickus,

He has a wife you know, do you know whats she's called? Incontinentia.......Incontinentia Buttocks '  :rofl:

  • Members
Posted
7 hours ago, toxo said:

Everything you've said above is ok except for handmaking the product. Buying product from China (say) would work because you can buy to test and if it doesn't work you can junk it and choose something else until you light on the items that sell. Making something by hand that might take an hour or three or four or a day is a different thing altogether. To make enough product to go through what you're advocating would take some time and at the end of the process it could come to nothing and you've wasted a lot of time. I have a very logical mind and so wish it was as easy as you say but the variables when handmaking are different. When you have supermarkets and online stores sell substandard stuff it's hard. As I've said before many of the public don't know or care where it comes from or what it's made of and some of those that do simply can't afford hand made stuff. This why I've said that where you market your product is really important. Of course, a couple of years down the line, if you're doing a good job you might start getting commissions and even small contracts but until then it can be hard to even get back what you've put in.

I get the fear!
Starting a business is scary, especially when R&D feels like it’s draining time and money.
But here’s the truth:

A/B Testing ≠ Huge Stock

You don’t need shelves full of products.
One prototype, a couple of good phone photos, and you’re ready to test. Especially if you want to test on social media! 
A/B testing is about interest, not inventory. Perfect for handmade.

R&D Isn’t Wasteful — It’s Smart

Every business, big or small, starts with prototypes.
Sharing early versions, showing the process, or testing reactions isn’t lost effort — it’s efficient.
R&D teaches you what will actually sell. There are no shortcuts, and there shouldn’t be.

Stop Comparing Handmade to Cheap Imports

Mass-manufactured and handmade are two different worlds.
Different markets. Different expectations. Different pricing.
If you keep attracting people who don’t value handmade work, the issue isn’t your product — it’s your branding and targeting.

If People Don’t Care About Your Quality, You’re Aiming at the Wrong Crowd!

Handmade was never meant for everyone.
So don’t try to sell to “everyone.” It won’t work.

How to Define Your Actual Customer

Create a clear profile of your ideal customer, like a blue print:

  • Who are they?

  • How old?

  • Income?

  • Style?

  • What do they value?

  • Why your product?

  • Where can you reach them?

Example: Luxury Handmade Leather Dog Collar

Let’s say you make a premium Italian leather collar with brass hardware.

Your customer?
Women 25–30 who love luxury fashion.
They hear “Italian leather,” and instantly think of designer handbags.
They earn 45–50k a year.
They want aesthetics, exclusivity, status — for themselves and their pets.
You’ll reach them on Instagram, TikTok, and through boutique-style soft launches.
They aren't bargain hunters. They want a vibe.

Position Yourself Smartly

Look at brands in your space and map out the market.
Find where you fit — and where you stand out. Your personal USP, if you will. 

Branding Matters More Than You Think

Handmade brands collapse not because the products are bad, but because their story is bland.

Have colours.
Have a logo that means something.
Know your story and say it with confidence.
People buy a feeling, not “just a collar.”

Tell a Better Story

Example:

Weak version:
“My granddad gave me his watch, strap was broken, I made a new one.”

Stronger version:
“When I was sixteen, my granddad gave me his watch. I adored the man. When the strap broke, I couldn’t find anything worthy of it — so I made one myself. It fit perfectly. Friends started asking for the same. That’s how this all began, and I still love creating pieces that make people light up when they finally get the strap they’ve dreamed of.”

Same facts.
Completely different emotional impact.

And yes — follow-up matters

A simple personal message a month later with cleaning tips or care advice?
A small newsletter with new products and maintenance tips?
Or at Christmas fairs: offer gift wrapping for a small upcharge in simple paper in your brand colours, sealed with a cheap sticker that carries your logo — instant “premium” feel and almost free advertising.

There are so many options.
The more personal and creative, the better — and none of it has to be expensive. A sheet of stickers costs what, here in Germany maybe 10€ for 500 pieces? Set a tiny marketing budget and actually plan with it. Small, thoughtful touches go a very long way.

That’s how you turn a one-time buyer into a loyal fan who recommends you to everyone.

If you still have questions about any of this, feel free to message me. I’m happy to point you in the right direction. â˜ș

Best, 
Tove

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...