Hi Reddevil,
I once ordered a batch of Craftsman oak tooling sides (2-3 oz) from Tandy and most of them are useable and clean. I think it all voice down to luck when making leather purchase online. All the best in your talk with the Tandy manager, I do hope they can provide a satisfactory resolution to your issue. Lastly, dont give up on this hobby, I think you do great wallet.
Regards,
Boon