Thanks ferg,
My burnishing does need work. The edges around the opening were intentionally left raw as I could not figure out a way to burnish around the tight radius's given the equipment I had at my disposal. The stitched edges had a very good burnish on them before I dyed. I glued it up and drilled the holes for stitching before I dyed it and it started falling apart instantly when the dye was applied. I stitched it up real quick but it left an unsightly edge. Lesson: dye first, glue after.
cseeger, I appreciate honesty. Don't hold back if you see a post I have started. That's why I post them. I am not going to re-do anything, what's done is done. Leather is relatively cheap. You brought up a really good point. I too, much prefer the finished appearance of lined cases. The leather I was working with was a very poor quality. The backside was awful. I tried sanding and the fiber "hairs" just got worse, and as ferg pointed out, my burnishing is inadequate and inconsistent (my words, not his:). Lesson: if you want top quality results, you have to spend the money on top quality materials.
A Smithy? I do very little "blacksmith" type work. All the hammering really ticks the neighbors off! That is another plus to leather working, the neighbors aren't giving me dirty looks every time I see them.
Bob