You can not, I repeat NOT. get Neatsfoot oil to shine. I don't know how many times I hear this again and again. Glycerin saddle soap can be buffed , but places like Mccall and Courts use Fiebings Bag Coat to give the saddles a shine. Yes you can use Saddle Lac or neat -Lac type of products, but they do seal the pores of the leather, but they shine!