First holster, give me your critique and criticism

[Red Cent]

I use the glycerin bar on dry firm edges only. And I use it after sanding and burnishing. If your edges have the look of a sponge, you got it too wet or it is spongy leather.  The bar won't help.

After beveling and sanding, a light wipe with a wet rag should set you up for burnishing and a glassy smooth edge. Nothing else is needed.  After I dye the edges I burnish with a well used dowel rod that will smooth the edges surprisingly well. If the dye causes some roughness, I will get out the glycerin bar. I never use saddle soap.