I'm in New Orleans and just purchased my first alligator hide last week from AmTan in Georgia. According to their rep, all their hides still have the fish & wildlife tags on them so they could tell me exactly where in Louisiana the hide came from. I ordered a wild belly, grade I/II, and it ran around $11 per cm for a hide 27 cm wide. That comes out to around $300 before shipping. They do not have a minimum for orders. It should arrive in a couple of days and I'll let you know how it looks. Check them out at amtan.com.
I like the idea of driving to Lafayette and being able to pick out hides by looks. Plus I could stop at Prejean's for some duck gumbo.