Members scottishshoemaker Posted January 22, 2011 Members Report Posted January 22, 2011 I'm looking to buy these but what volume is best 1, 2 or 3?. I know some may say depends what you want to make, but looking at the picture of books some patterns are doubled up. So can anyone recomend one of the above. Quote
Members Tina Posted January 22, 2011 Members Report Posted January 22, 2011 Hi, you need to start with number 1, in book 2 & 3 they only make references to see in book1 and so on. It is not freestanding books in the true sense. Quote
Russ Posted January 22, 2011 Report Posted January 22, 2011 (edited) Depends on what you want to make In all seriousness, I have all three. Volume 1 has a majority of smaller items, sheaths, small cases such as eye glass cases or ammo carriers, etc. It also has a lot of basic info that you would use in other projects, such as installing dees, burnishing edges, and some basics of hand sewing. Vol 2 has medium sized cases and an extensive section on handles, zippers, and locks, and some info on making patters, making and installing welts, and several types of zipper cases. Vol 3 goes to bigger cases, a guitar case, brief case, several rifle scabbards, and a golf club bag! I've found that most of these items would not pay well because of the cost of materials, and the amount that the custom made item would cost. That is just my experience though, others may have a different customer base. I found Vol 1 to be best when I was getting started...gave basic info and plans. Vol 2 helped me with toiletry bags, portfolios, and basic boxes. The books are freestanding if you have basic knowledge of leathercraft; just look at the cover and see what you'd like to make. Otherwise, I'd start with the small, easy projects in Vol 1 and work your way up. Hi, you need to start with number 1, in book 2 & 3 they only make references to see in book1 and so on. It is not freestanding books in the true sense. Most of the Stohlman books are like that...they repeat sections of other material, and refer to other sections for you to go look at. I'm sure some of it was marketing, and some of it was "filler" material. I'm looking to buy these but what volume is best 1, 2 or 3?. I know some may say depends what you want to make, but looking at the picture of books some patterns are doubled up. So can anyone recomend one of the above. Edited January 22, 2011 by Russ Quote
Contributing Member Jordan Posted January 23, 2011 Contributing Member Report Posted January 23, 2011 Each one progresses or builds on the other loosely, delving into more advanced techniques as they go along. I found all three worth it. I did wait until they were on sale so I got 3 for the price of about 2. Jordan Quote
Members scottishshoemaker Posted January 23, 2011 Author Members Report Posted January 23, 2011 Thanks for all the info guys n gals. They are on sale at Tandy so may go for all three. Cheers. Quote
Members gary Posted January 23, 2011 Members Report Posted January 23, 2011 Thanks for all the info guys n gals. They are on sale at Tandy so may go for all three. Cheers. I may be a bit late replying to this but I have all 3 and use 1 and 2 mostly with the occasional dip into No 3. Do you want me to scan the contents pages for you so you can have a deek before you buy? Gary Quote
Members Gawdzilla Posted January 24, 2011 Members Report Posted January 24, 2011 The best tip I got from Vol. 1 was to make a block of wood in the size and shape you wanted the bag to be so you could know you were getting the dimensions correct as you went on. That has saved me a lot of time. It's also left me with a collection of odd shaped chunks of wood. (So be sure to write what it's for on the wood before you forget.) Quote
Members robs456 Posted January 25, 2011 Members Report Posted January 25, 2011 Get all three if you can, or just the first and second (in that order) if money is an issue. For someone just making sheaths and small cases the first one is enough, and if you're making bags with handles Vol 2 is essential. Each of them also goes more in depth about a specific subject. In Vol 1 it is attaching straps, hardware and belt loops. Vol 2 handles handles (harhar) of all types. And Vol 3 IIRC has a good piece about different linings. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.