While I usually lurk on this forum I read your post and though I would offer the following:
The age old question is: What is the"best" type of holster to buy. I just retired after 36 years in law enforcement and have been lookingfor that answer for a long time. I have several "boxes" of holsters as I have tried to address every type of concealmentneed.
The answer is: It depends. The first thing I would caution against is, disregard what you may have read in themagazine articles. Or what some trainer may have said about the "best" holsteror what you may need. The questions to ask are somewhat more complex to get to a holster that may work for you.
Body type: Small frame, large frame, tall, short, thickor thin waist. Any physical limitationsin terms of flexibility (I have a shoulder issue as an example).<br style="mso-special-character: line-break;"><br style="mso-special-character: line-break;">Style of dress / Climate: I look for a holster that is relativelycomfortable, then choose the clothing that will conceal the firearm. In other words how will you be dressed andwhat is the climate. As an example Ineed to buy pants and belt at least 2 inches larger if I wearing a IWBholster. Jeans 1.75 " belt, dockers, 1"belt.
Duration and physical activities: think about what your daily activity is,standing, sitting, crawling, stooping, reaching, jumping, and running. You holster need to retain your firearm whileengaged in vigorous physical activity such as running away or towards somethingsuch as a threat or cover. Almost forgot,how long will you be carrying the firearm 8, 10, 12 hours. Side note:Carrying a 1911A1 will two mags, handcuffs, badge, OC and baton while in civilianclothing around all day can become physically taxing.
Concealment: Where or what will you be doing and howcritical is that your handgun remain concealed. Do you need to stay concealed so no one around you knows your arecarrying or is it a casual concealment environment such as off duty lawenforcement. Is printing an issue, ifyou reach for an item and your firearm is exposed will that create aproblem. As you sit down will yourholster and belt creak, or make a sound when the butt of your handgun hits theplastic seat at Mc "D's". If someonebumps into you in a crowd will they impact your firearm?
Handgun: How big is the handgun you want tocarry? There are trade off's witheach. What does the gun weigh? 1911 vs KetTec 9mm, there is a worldapart, thick Glock or Smith & Wessonor wheel gun with 2 inch cylinder. Any sharpedges or angles that will become a problem in concealment design. An FN 5.7 as opposed to a S&W J framechiefs special it makes a difference.
Insummary: Holster selection / Designis based on several criteria. In myexperience this includes:
· A combination of speed, safety, durability,and a key component for concealed carry, concealability. Also retention while engaged in vigorousactivity.
· There are some safety areas that cannot becompromised – Covered Trigger.
As I said "it depends" and it only my opinion and you everyone hasone of those…
Regards