The OP used Eco-Flow, which is some of the worst garbage ever created IMO... especially for items like holster that will see wear and tear. The Pro Waterstain is another creature altogether and is much better in my experience.
jpaltan, what color Eco-Flow did you use? Personally I like when the browns are uneven and marbled looking, adds character. At any rate, you can always go black. After everything is dried and buffed you can seal it up with some resolene, or satin sheen, or super sheen.
Welcome to LW.net!