Another update and thoughts - I received my hide from Wickett and Craig this morning as promised by Glenn. Nicely wrapped with a bundle of swatches of their leather selection. Upon opening the wrapping, my initial thought was "very nice" then I grabbed a piece of leather that I bought from Tandy, their #1 grade and compared the two.
The difference is night and day. My next response was "WOW". The W & C hide has excellent, even color throughout, very little marking (no brands and only 2 small abrasions) and the thickness is even throughout. I had it split to 5/6 from 9/10, they did a great job. The back has only about 2% roughed sections, all at the edges in mostly unused areas so the main hide is just about perfect. This is on their #3 special grade that was on overstock sale.
I still like having a local Tandy for the commeraderie and parts, etc. and the folks there are great. But, I will definitely be buying my big hides from W & C going forward. I just can't justify using lower grade hide at the same/higher prices just to save time for shipping.