Normally it's the same thing for me. I think the difference is in the paddle itself. I wanted a smaller paddle and came across these accidentally while making holsters of another style for someone else. For some reason these paddles weigh absolutely nothing. And the way that they sit on my hip has been absolutely perfect. That coupled with the fact that leather just doesn't seem to weigh that much, means that the only weight I'm really feeling is the weight of the gun itself. With the larger 1911 it took a little bit of getting used to however most of the time with my job I'm wearing suspenders over a button-up dress shirt so the suspenders alleviate the weight. With the smaller 1911 honestly cannot even feel the weight. I did make myself a belt out of 15 oz Herman oak veg tan. No liner. However the belt does a very good job of keeping my trousers up. Thank you for the comments. I learned a long time ago the kiss method of doing things. Keep it simple. So plain is the way to go for me.
I appreciate the feedback. I just use the old kiss method. Keep it simple stupid. I'm not a huge fan of taking the easy way, however this one just seemed to work out for me. Still lots of stitching while sewing in the liner and let me tell you putting that welt onto the edge was a bear, but I'm genuinely happy with the way it turned out.