After 4 yrs of using eco-flo antique gel I finally switched to Fiebings antique paste today. I had, what I thought was, good results with the eco-flo but had bought some fiebings paste after reading so many posts regarding how much better it was. I have had the paste for about 1yr now but still hadn't used it. I'd tried it on some scraps a few times then tossed in into my dye drawer and decided I would stick with the eco-flo. (I ditched the eco flo dye a few years ago for the fiebings/angelus dyes) Today I just couldn't get the antique result I wanted, so with some trepidation, I dug out the Fiebings and ended up loving it.