Thanks, it helps a lot to know what other people find to be normal. I agree that it'd be silly to expect perfection, and I usually allow for 4-8 square feet of waste (or at least, places where I cut out straps or pockets because you have to work around scars or wrinkles). If I didn't mind taking sandpaper to the whole thing and purposely distressing it all to match, I would probably keep it. It would even be kind of fun, as I've been wanting to try distressing something. However, I was purposely trying to spend more money to buy better leather that I could charge more money for than an economy Tandy hide. So much for that. What do you make with bridle leather? I'd love to see some pictures.