Well, I haven't been around as long as you guys seem to have been, but I'll throw in my opinion -- not that you asked for it. My first saddle weighed nearly 60 pounds. Being new to the riding world, I thought that was just the way it was. Then I started looking around at some of the whys and wherefores, and then reached my own conclusions. I don't ride all day every day, but there are many days that I have spent all day ( more than 8 hours) in the saddle. And I've had to lug my own saddle around to different parts of the country (and Mexico), so when I made my saddle (as opposed to trail saddles for little old blue-haired ladies) I studied up on what needs to be stout and what doesn't. The saddle I ride now weighs just over 34 pounds. It has seen seven good years of work, including roping my share of about 3,000 calves per year. It was made stout, for all day work, and as light as I could get away with. As you can see, my manhood isn't tied up in hauling (or making my horse haul) a saddle that's primary virtue is how much it weighs. Naturally I take care of my gear and I watch for cracks, rips, tears, and loos stitches. That said, my saddle was painstakingly made to exactly what I wanted -- full custom, so I could get away with some things that you never could in a production model. I like the weight, the sturdiness, and would compare mine to anyone's for wear per workload placed on it. Just my humble input.