I used to dye my holsters. I had very good success with the new water stains from Tandy Leather. But now, something new.
I tried my best to stay with Herman Oak or wicket and Craig leather. But the ordering process for drum dyed leather from Herman oak is non existent. I was told I would have to by 30 sides of one color. (sorry for rambling)
So now, I am into my second batch of leather from RJF Leather. I have bought the #1 backs in each color they offer. I really like the leather. It is North American hides (I think US) and is tanned in Mexico. I wanted to stay with US tanned because of the buy America thing.
Bottom line, I really like the RJF leather. cuts, molds, dyes, tools, stamps oils as good as Herman Oak and maybe better than Wicket and Craig.