Restoration is a funny thing, some are happy to repair the original , but the repair must stand out as a eyesaw so people know its not original, often on old buildings. They take a 500 plus year old cathedral and insit the new blocks of stone stand out a gleaming new colour whilst the surrounding blocks are covered in 500 years of grime
Some others want to retain the grubby worn out patena with all the faults remaining and value it highly even if it looks a mess
Others make it back to a serviceable object that can be used and looks great maybe 95% of its original look
Depending on your most modern point of view you either hate whatever was done or love it
Me i think what you have done is great and its now a practical object that can be used for its original function